Friday, June 16, 2017

Marie Severin and Bill Everett

In the early 1970’s Marie Severin was producing a plethora of covers for Marvel’s growing line of comics. Severin not only created cover roughs for other artists to complete (including Jack Kirby, John and Sal Buscema, Dick Ayers and Neal Adams), but penciled many of her own covers as well. Some of those covers were clearly rushed; lettering was often sloppy, with word balloons and copy that distracted from the art. There were, however, several gems that stood out; some of the most distinctive bore the stylized signature “7-EV,” which translated to Marie Severin pencils; Bill Everett inks.

Marie Severin's cover preliminary to Thor # 186 (March 1971) and John Buscema's published version, inked by John Verpoorten. In this instance it was decided, perhaps by editor Stan Lee, to draw Hela as a full-figure instead of Marie's original head shot. While many artists adhered closely to Severin's compositions a few altered her designs to suit their own sense of storytelling.  

 Color guide to "War Dance!", Frontline Combat # 13, July-August 1953. Pencils and inks by brother John Severin, script by Jerry De Fuccio, letters by Ben Oda.  

Marie Severin started her career at the prestigious and influential EC Comics in the 1950s, doing production work and coloring practically their entire line of crime, horror, war, science-fiction and humor titles. Her vibrant hues added another level of quality to EC’s coterie of creators. 

In the early 1960’s Marie began working for Marvel full-time, at first as production assistant to Sol Brodsky, but her duties grew after publisher Martin Goodman saw her art on a house ad. This led to an assignment penciling "Doctor Strange," followed by the Hulk and Sub-Mariner. Her storytelling skills were immediately obvious and while her efforts focused primarily on superhero fare there was always a sense that she wasn't taking this stuff seriously; a knowing wink at the audience. This was exemplified when Marie was allowed to lampoon Marvel's top heroes in Not Brand Echh. The title ran for 13 issues, from 1967-69, and Marie's art was represented in every one. Marie continued to be a force at Marvel for decades, contributing to the comic book field as both an artist and colorist, but her greatest talent, arguably, was her ability to find humor in life's absurdities and bring it to life with pen and brush.  
Marie caricatured most of Marvel superheroes (along with the then-current movie BONNIE AND CLYDE) on the cover of Not Brand Echh # 9, August 1968.



Early on Bill Everett displayed a flair for the unusual as this cover demonstrates. Amazing Mystery Funnies Vol 2; # 2, December 1939.     

 Bill Everett was not only one of the industries pioneers but a versatile creator who could do it all; write,pencil, ink, letter and color. From his earliest days Everett had a distinctive style, inspired in part by comic strip artists including Milton Caniff and Roy Crane (whose technique of employing Ben-Day to create shading he adopted). Everett created many original characters, but Prince Namor, the Sub-Mariner became an immediate hit, holding the attention of the buying public. Namor was an offbeat hero who inhabited an undersea kingdom and often fought against the human race. After his initial run in the 1940s he was revived for a brief period in the 1950s; less than a decade later Sub-Mariner was incorporated into the Marvel lineup by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby.
   
 

Young Men # 26, March 1954. Everett's Sub-Mariner feature included some of his favorite storytelling tropes: use of elements - especially water - to suggest a feeling of weight and depth, a somewhat cartoonish but expressive line and depiction of beautiful women. Everett art, lettering and possible story. Image from the reprint in Marvel Masterworks: Atlas Era Masterworks Volume 1.   

Everett continued to produce superb work decade after decade, working on war, western, jungle, romance, horror and other genre material. After leaving comics for a period of time Everett took on the assignment to create a new superhero for Stan Lee in 1964, Daredevil, with assistance from Jack Kirby. He returned to Marvel full-time in 1965, where he drew "Doctor Strange," "The Incredible Hulk," and, eventually, returned to his beloved character, Sub-Mariner.    

By the late 1960s Everett was often employed to ink (and color) other artist’s pencils. His crisp, detailed rendering made Everett one of the best in the field. Everett inked some of Marvel’s top artist’s, including Jim Steranko, Gene Colan and Jack Kirby.  While his inking style was elaborate, Everett rarely overpowered the pencils; he instead complimented the art, adding another layer - like frosting on a cake.
Gene Colan and Bill Everett's rendition of Spider-Man, from Captain America and the Falcon # 137, May 1971.
Jack Kirby on pencils and Bill Everett on inks; two masters of comic art. On this page from Thor # 179, November 1969, Everett gets to ink the oceans he so loved. A Kirby/Everett Sub-Mariner would have been wonderful to see.  
In 1970 Everett inked a series of covers over Marie Severin’s pencils. Below I've assembled (I believe) every pairing of the two dynamic artists. While many inkers complimented Marie’s pencils, including Frank Giacoia, Herb Trimpe, Dan Adkins and Tom Palmer, Everett’s embellishment meshed perfectly with her style. Marie often designed busy covers utilizing background characters; Everett added depth with his intricate inks. They lent their talents to a number of superhero covers, including Daredevil, Iron-Man and Spider-Man (in Marvel Tales) and produced exceptional art for the mystery and monster line, including Tower of Shadows, Chamber of Darkness and Where Monsters Dwell. Oddly enough, with one exception the team never drew covers for characters they were closely associated with (i.e. Sub-Mariner and the Hulk).  

                       Note: All the covers are suspected to be colored by Marie.



Severin and Everett's first cover collaboration was one of their very best. Everett was at home in the horror and suspense genre, having drawn countless exceptional covers for Stan Lee in the 1950s. Detailed buildings and fearful citizens populate this scene, with faces peering out of windows. The muted colors add considerably to the mood. Sam Rosen letters. Chamber of Darkness # 4, April 1970.   


Marvel Tales # 26, May 1970. Image from the Grand Comics Database. 

Severin and Everett only drew the top image of Spider-Man, based on Steve Ditko's dramatic representation from Amazing Spider-Man # 33. Jack Kirby and Chic Stone stats of Thor and The Human Torch take up the bottom portion of the published cover. The original artwork from Heritage Auctions is seen below. 


The Severin/Everett team really outdid themselves on the mystery/monster covers. This deliciously rendered cover includes a busy background, although the coloring keeps the focus on the foreground figures.  And, no, that's not the Puppet Master applying makeup. Can YOU spot the Severin-Everett signature? Sam Rosen letters, Tower of Shadows # 5, May 1970. 

A typical sight for residents of New York City - a giant ant loitering in the street! Where Monsters Dwell was a reprint title that featured pre-hero monster stories. The interior story that relates to the cover scene, reprinted from Strange Tales # 73, February, 1960 and drawn by Jack Kirby, was inked by Bill Everett a decade earlier. The "Sev/Ev" signature can be seen on the lower right side, next to the stoop. Sam Rosen letters, Where Monsters Dwell # 3, May 1970.

Iron Man Special # 1, August 1970, is the only instance where Marie penciled an Everett inked Sub-Mariner. Their signature can be observed next to Iron Man's left foot. Sam Rosen lettering. 
Another water based background. Signature on the sunken ship to the right. Daredevil # 67, Aug 1970.  



Close-up of the stylized "E7V" signature. Variations appeared on most of their covers.


This is my least favorite of their mystery-oriented covers. I suspect Marie may have made solo alterations on the falling man; perhaps the original was rejected by the Comics Code and Marie toned it down? Whatever the case, the figure doesn't appear to be inked by Everett to my eye. There are some nice touches, though, particularly their signature on the underside of a sneaker. Chamber of Darkness # 6, August 1970. Sam Rosen letters.

Marie and Bill were picked to inaugurate the cover of Astonishing Tales # 1, August 1970. The split format leaves less room for detail and has a rushed quality to it, in particular the Dr. Doom section, which may include alterations before publication by Marie or another hand. Morrie Kuramoto and Sam Rosen letters.  
Crowd scenes were a staple of Severin-Everett covers. One drawback in this period was an over-reliance on word balloons to explain the story. It can be argued that a powerful image by talented craftsman should be able to draw a prospective reader in. Iron Man # 29, September 1970.        

The third Severin-Everett Iron-Man cover includes more fleeing crowds! Their signature appears on the building to the right. Iron Man # 30, October, 1970.  
This time Severin/Everett produced a full Spider-Man cover with strong results, marred again by an abundance of word balloons. Note the detailed buildings and characters looking out windows. The truck in the lower left hand corner sports their signature. Marvel Tales # 28, October 1970.



The team take a final crack at Iron Man and Everett inks Daredevil once again in the reprint title Marvel Super-Heroes (# 28, October 1970).  

The Severin-Everett collaboration ended after seven months and twelve covers. Everett probably cut down on his Marvel assignments at this point when he began producing black and white magazines for Skywald (detailed in an earlier post): 

Marie continued to work diligently on a variety of assignments; as head colorist, cover artist and, of course, weaving her satiric skills on humor titles, including Spoof, Arrgh and Crazy magazine. A rare treat was her teaming with brother John, who added a meticulous layer of detail to Marie's pencils for a brief run in Kull the Conqueror. In later years Marie worked with Sol Brodsky in the Special Projects department, developing children's books. All told she worked at Marvel for over thirty years and continued to draw and color comics into the 2000's.  


Besides the aforementioned brother/sister team-up in Kull, Marie and John parodied Tarzan in Spoof # 2, November 1972.  Two decades earlier, John illustrated Harvey Kurtzman's satire of the Jungle Lord in Mad # 2 (December 1952-January 1953). Kid sister Marie was involved in that story as well - as colorist. Roy Thomas script, Sam Rosen letters (and - who else? - Marie Severin colors). 

********************************

...I Had always been interested in anything nautical, anything to do with the sea  -- ever since I was born I guess. Everett on Everett, an Interview by Roy Thomas, Alter Ego # 11, June 1978  
From time to time in the mid-1960s Bill Everett was involved with the Sub-Mariner feature in Tales to Astonish, first as inker over Gene Colan and Jerry Grandenetti and later as co-plotter/penciler, but the character had changed significantly and the updated version was not particularly to his liking. In 1972, though, Everett was allowed to author his creation once again, taking the character in an unusual direction; combining the trappings of 1940s-era comics with a modern sensibility. 

Everett's final go-round on his creation was an artistic leap and - I might argue - some of the most impressive work of his career. Although Everett had been drawing the ocean depths for decades, his ability to create the sensation of an otherworldly, breathtakingly rich world was heightened in these stories, perhaps due to years of honing his craft. Script and art by Everett; lettering by John Costanza, Sub-Mariner # 50, June 1972.    


The last Severin/Everett "collaboration" was drawn in 1971 for Roy Thomas, to accompany his interview with the artist. Marie drew a caricature of Bill; Everett illustrated the surrounding characters. Unfortunately, it would not see publication until seven years later, in Alter Ego # 11, June 1978. Everett was never to see it, though, as he passed away on February, 20, 1973, at the age of 56. 
Both separately and as a team Marie Severin and Bill Everett epitomize the talent, creativity and, quite often, the pure sense of delight in cartooning that flows from their pen and brush. They were also gifted at being multi-talented; able to pencil, ink, color, letter and write - tools that served them well in the comics industry. Much of what they have produced is worthy of study, appreciation, analysis and admiration.    

14 comments:

Kid said...

Interesting post, Nick. However, I have to confess that I much preferred Colletta's inks to Everett's on Thor, which looked much too cartoony when Bill inked it. I read somewhere that the Everett-inked issues of Thor didn't sell as well, but I've no idea by how much the sales dropped if it's true.

His 'Sufferin' Shad!" Sub-Mariner strips were classy stuff indeed, and I even enjoyed his '60s strips - although his depiction of technology seemed out-dated, being very 1950-ish in design. (Cast your mind back to that robot from outer-space he fought as an example.)

Keep up the good work.

Nick Caputo said...

Kid,

always a pleasure to have tour input here. Colletta certainly brought a distinctive look to Kirby's Thor, and some of the work was quite nice, but I really enjoyed Everett's inking over Kirby. Along with Stone, Ditko, Wood and Sinnott, he is one of my favorite inkers over Kirby.

Everett's style did seem more antiquated than more contemporary artists, but it added a charm of its own, in my opinion.

John Porcellino said...

Where Monsters Dwell #3 is my favorite comic book cover of all time-- Glad to see it remarked upon here!

Nick Caputo said...

John,

You have excellent taste!

benjaminherman said...

Great blog post. I appreciate you putting in so many different examples of Marie Severin and Bill Everett's work. They really did make a great team. I'm a huge old-school Marvel Zombie, but even so I am not really familiar with either Severin or Everett's contribbutions at the company in the 1970s. So I found this to be a very informative piece.

Nick Caputo said...

Hi benjaminherman,

I'm very glad you enjoyed the post and hope you'll find future posts equally interesting.

The Old Curmudgeon said...

I think the "7-Ev" signature was intended to be read as "Sev 'n' Ev," meaning Severin and Everett.

Everett was one of the all-time greats. He not only was one of Kirby's best inkers ever, but was my favorite inker over Colan's pencils. Colan and Everett teamed on a great early Sub-Mariner strip in Tales to Astonish, and did wonderful work on the Black Widow strip in Amazing Adventures.

I couldn't agree more about Everett's work on Sub-Mariner shortly before his death. That, and his 1950's Sub-Mariner issues, were his career best in my opinion.

I never did understand the point of creating new cover art for reprint titles. For example, compare the cover of Where Monsters Dwell No. 3 with the cover of Strange Tales 73, found at http://www.comics.org/issue/15509/cover/4/
Sev 'n' Ev's rendition of Grotto was almost copied from Kirby's original. I can't think of any instances in which a Marvel reprint cover in the late 60's or 70's improved on the original. Did Stan think a new cover somehow would help sales?

Nick Caputo said...

Hi Old Crumudgeon,

There were probably a number of reasons why new covers were used instead of originals. Sometimes it might have been Stan wanting to use new artwork, but other times it may have been because they couldn't find (or didn't have a good stat) of the original.

While I agree that often the originals were better than the new versions, there were quite a few worthwhile new covers by the likes of Gil Kane, Jim Starlin, John Buscema and others. The western reprints, in particular, have some excellent cover art by John Severin and Gil Kane.

Michael Tuz said...

These are two of my all-time favorite artists, and when they worked together the results were downright magical! Gotta go with Tower of Shadows #5 for my favorite of the covers posted here, but the horror covers are all pretty fabulous.

In my mind, Bill Everett was the best to ever ink Gene Colan, with that couple of issues of Captain America being their finest hour.
Everett seemed to continue to improve as an artist throughout his career, and I agree wholeheartedly that those final issues of Sub'Mariner contained his best work. Hard to believe he's been gone for over four decades. I was in my senior year of high school when he died...

Nick Caputo said...

Hi Mike,

I wish they had produced more covers together, particularly in the mystery/horror/monster genre.

Colan had a few fine inkers such as Tom Palmer and Syd Shores, but I agree that Everett was one of the best. One can only imagine what wonders Everett could have crafted had he lived, I suspect he would have been in the category of a John Severin or Russ Heath.

Marcus said...

Great post! I, also liked Everett's work on the Hulk in Tales to Astonish. He had a lush inking style and was great on Kirby. Imagine if he inked the whole Thor run.

Michael Tuz said...

Marcus,
Wow, what a wonderful thought!

Russ said...

One of the more amazing ink jobs Everett did was on Barry Smith for the Ka-Zar strip. This was early in Smith's career (Conan was up to #6) and Everett really seemed to grasp what Smith was doing in a way that inkers like Sal Buscema and Frank Giacoia did not. Aside from sheer artistic skill, I think the difference was enough respect for the vision of the younger artist to really examine what he was given and approach it sensitively. I'd say that obtains with Steranko and Kirby as well.

Michael Tuz said...

Russ,
Yeah, that was gorgeous work. Everett brought a high level of refinement to everything he inked, a refinement that was perfectly suited to Barry Smith's style.
One of the joys of being a fan of Marvel Comics in the late sixties/early seventies was watching the rapid development of Barry Smith. I think his brief run on Ka-Zar is an oft overlooked gem from that period.